Site Map Fuzzy Boundaries

by Carl Strang

In the previous post I described my winter project of creating new maps showing all the sites where I have found each singing insect species in the Chicago region. A few of these produced surprises. Take the Texas bush katydid (Scudderia texensis), for instance.

Texas bush katydid

The all-sites map for Texas bush katydids.

The proportion of sites where I have observed this species is noticeably higher west of the Indiana border. Texas bush katydids occur through much of the eastern U.S., but they seem to thin out significantly in the eastern part of this region. I had no idea until I finished this map.

A similar surprise awaited in the maps for long-tailed meadow katydids (Conocephalus attenuatus) and black-sided meadow katydids (C. nigropleurum), two small wetland species.

Long-tailed meadow katydid

Black-sided meadow katydid, one of our most colorful singing insects

The all-sites map for long-tailed meadow katydids.

The all-sites map for black-sided meadow katydids.

As you can see, these are two species I don’t run into very often. What intrigues me is that I have found both only in the northern part of the region. Historically, at least, their ranges have extended well into southern Indiana, but is that still the case? Might these be examples of species losing the southern part of their ranges to climate change? This is one question I don’t think I have enough lifetime left to pursue myself, but perhaps others will be able to show that these species still are around farther south.

A final case for today is that of the tinkling ground cricket (Allonemobius tinnulus).

Tinkling ground cricket. Reddish tones distinguish this woodland-edge species.

Tinkling ground cricket all sites map

Here the map doesn’t tell the whole story. The sites in Indiana and the more southern Illinois counties have lots of tinkling ground crickets. The Cook, Kane and DuPage County sites represent observations of single individuals or, at most, fewer than ten. This seems to point to a drastic thinning northward, and makes the Lake County (Illinois) and Walworth County (Wisconsin) observations seem suspect. But going back to my field notes, I find that the Illinois Beach State Park and Lulu Lake Nature Preserve observations were of large, if isolated populations. What may distinguish them is the sand soil at Illinois Beach and similar gravelly soil at Lulu Lake. In DuPage, Kane and that part of Cook County the soils are clay based. So why haven’t I found tinkling ground crickets on the sandy soils of municipal parks in Wisconsin’s Racine and Kenosha Counties? Scientists love mysteries.

1 Comment

  1. February 6, 2019 at 6:20 pm

    Another fascinating post, Carl!

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Google photo

You are commenting using your Google account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s

%d bloggers like this: